HELP! please evaluate my daughters swing

[FiveFrameSwing]

 

[FiveFrameSwing]

 

[4 girl's dad]

what was I thinking....

I should follow my own advice.

 

[FiveFrameSwing]

Gah, you so smart.. what was I thinking....

I should follow my own advice.

What you 'were' thinking has evolved.

At one point you were thinking that the "FP swing" was more difficult to master than the "SP swing". It was your opinion at that time that the "SP swing" was less difficult to master than the "FP swing". Later you didn't recall thinking that the "SP swing" was easier. When that was clearly laid out for you, you thought you were thinking of "pitching".

You provide another good data point for Soonershok. We have folks here that make mistakes and/or rapidly change what they are thinking. Just another reason to consider adopting simple filters to help differentiate between 'good' and 'potentially-not-so-good' advice.

 

[_MIA_]

FFS, if I might suggest something. You seem to know something about both types of swings. Can you lay out your thoughts regarding the similarities and differences
in both.

IMO, and you may disagree (in which case your insight would still be valuable), since she plays both equally and is having a difficult time mastering her one swing, nevermind trying to master 2, would
be that she work on the commonalities between the two swings and that would get her 3/4 of the way there (assuming there are a lot of similarities..which to my eye there are).

 

[FiveFrameSwing]

Pattar ... my response appears to have been deleted. We'll have to pick up the discussion elsewhere.

 

[_MIA_]

Pattar ... my response appears to have been deleted. We'll have to pick up the discussion elsewhere.

I saw it and while valid, I still think a discussion of the similarities/differences might help the OP and/or others who are struggling with the same "swing juggling act". Anyway,
not a big deal.

As an aside, based upon the clips you posted, it looks like my DD had (she is improving on the things that were discussed
in my thread)/has a good SP swing..LOL.

 

[FiveFrameSwing]

I saw it and while valid, I still think a discussion of the similarities/differences might help the OP and/or others who are struggling with the same "swing juggling act". Anyway,
not a big deal.

Yes, the post was valid.

 

[_MIA_]

yes, the post was valid.

lol......

Edit: The site had issues this morning and that may have been the reason for the post
being deleted as opposed to the reason being the content.

 

[Shawn]