Perfect swing?

[TDS]

Would anyone take this swing?

Butter, not long ago it was considered a push swing by some.

 

[TDS]

Coach Bob, Rich, don't remember if there were others.. I am sure there were more since Rich called it.

 

[Buttermaker]

I agree with Shawn channeling Nyman that we can only see what we see...

 

[crankermo]

I was and still am in the camp of that being a push swing. 99.9% of softball dads would gladly take that swing for their daughters but that doesn't mean it couldn't be better.

Ask yourself can there be more whip created?

 

[Buttermaker]

Well I guess when someone produces a better college hitter I will listen. Otherwise is all opinion and speculation.

 

[crankermo]

Isn't that what hitting instruction is in a nutshell

 

[TDS]

I guess it depends on how one see's the cause of the whip. I see the core responsible for the change in direction/whip.

 

[crankermo]

Exactly TDS where I and others view the hand pivot point coupled with the resistance believe that is where whip is created.

This battle has been fought on the internet for decades and it will continue when we are gone I'm sure, lol

 

[Buttermaker]

Yup. But, it gets tiring to hear people parrot someone that hasn't produced anything and has been around for over 10 years. Shouldn't he have produced someone by now? Instead he has cried that college coaches tinkered with an amazing swing he taught. Sure, it happens all the time but if his material was so gosh darn good there should have been someone that hit so freaking amazing that a college coach would not have dreamed with screwing with him/her. Mendoza is not a model to use by she hit. Same with many others. How Altuve? Would you teach that? Harper swing sucked according to some.

Happy New Year!

 

[TDS]

Another one that creates change in direction using her core.. But I guess since her change in direction is tighter it's not a push.