Posey,
"Your opinion on hip turn seems very much like that advocated by Dr. Chris Yeager. I'm not arguing with the back foot push, but IMO your pelvic muscles also help in the process of turning the hips, or in getting the hips to lead the way. Hips lead while the hands stay back as rotation inititates into toe touch.
The hands are NOT left behind in a disconnected manner - everything is connected as hips lead. Or better yet, hips lead as the hitter rotates into toe touch and begins to "sit to hit" as tilt over plate/lateral tilt and turn takes place at heel drop. X-factor stretch is created through the combination of hips leading AND scap loading as the hands/arms get a running start (my preference) which may include a tip and rip upper torso loading. As launch is underway, the hands get flat immediately through the reversal of elbow positions (back elbow slotting), with the front elbow getting into the pitch plane.
The ball is then hit in a palm up/palm down position on a slightly up swing path. That's the way I see it, anyway. This stuff is difficult, for me at least, to write about and explain. I need my friend Tom here."
Mike
Hey Guru what level of ball did you play? I hope you have the guts to look at A-Rod swing the bat because he does'nt sit to hit or weather vane or any other made up guru sayings from Epstein. STOP DRINKING THE KOOL-AID! P.S. Itwould be nice if one of you could actually played.
Guru-
I don't know how you could say that linear hitting makes no sense. Isn't the purpose of a good swing to get your body weight behind the ball? Why would you throw your hips and take out the entire bottom half of your body? Think of it this way, if you wanted to push a 100lb sled to first base would you open your hips and then try to push? No because you wouldnt be able to push it with just your arms so why would you do that when a balls coming? you may have bat speed but i hope it's an inside pitch and you're playing on a round field otherwise you won't make it very far in the game.