- Jul 14, 2008
- 1,798
- 63
Secondly......Huff stated that by placing your arm behind you PALM UP.......You would be in the anatomical "neutral postion".......In fact he said this more then once in this thread.......Infact he said it within his last few posts.......
Show me! This is my whole debate and source of my question. Show me! Behind the back, the only way you can achieve palm up is to rotate the ball of the humerus in the rotator cuff. That is what I said. No, elbow flexion is quite simple; palm up, bend your elbow. I wasn't distorting the argument! Do you think people can't read as well as you can. You either are a liar or read at a fifth grade level. If you are so convinced of your righteousness, then don't distort, lie, or post half truths.
Oh no.........Did I mis-type what you said?...........Was it "palm down behind you" you said several times was anatomically neutral?........Then finally later correct yourself to say palm out?........Oh well.......
Palm down/Palm up.........."You can parse it all you want", you were wrong.........(sound familiar?)
I guess we're all guilty at some point aren't we..........
Behind the back, the only way you can achieve palm up is to rotate the ball of the humerus in the rotator cuff. That is what I said. No, elbow flexion is quite simple; palm up, bend your elbow. I wasn't distorting the argument! Do you think people can't read as well as you can. You either are a liar or read at a fifth grade level. If you are so convinced of your righteousness, then don't distort, lie, or post half truths.
I don't know why your still here.........We've proven that palm up is a desired position..........And heck......It may even be "anatomically neutral"..........Since at 9:00 we're no longer in the sagittal plane who can tell?.......IF, in the anatomically neutral postion, the palm faces the same direction as the bicep/humerus...........And at 9:00 the bicep/humerus is facing up/back.......Wouldn't neutral when referencing humerus through palm have the palm facing the same direction as the bicep STILL?........So if the bicep is facing up........Might "neutral" also have the palm facing up?.........EXACTLY the same as the Anatomical neutral position when "hanging" down bicep/humerus/palm forward?.....
Hmmmmm..........
I think, and you can correct me if I'm wrong.........You said Ana. Neutral was technically a fully supinated position......Proven with elbow flexion from neutral...........IOW.......You can't supinate any further from the anatomically "neutral position"......Isn't that also true with palm up at 9:00?..........
You sure Palm OUT at 9:00 is Ana. Neutral?...........
Oh well.........We can't ALL be right can we.........