Ball breaks glove - Hit or error?

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

May 6, 2015
2,397
113
When a routine grounder hits a rock in the infield, resulting in a ball being mishandled and dropped, it's an error. Is it "fair" that the rock interfered with the play?
some might argue that the routine grounder hitting a rock and taking an odd hop might make it no longer routine (same way a pop fly to SS on very windy day might not be considered IFR).
 
May 29, 2015
3,815
113
No real dog in this fight (I’m just concerned with out/safe) ... but I keep going back to this thought (along the lines of a broken bat, etc.) ... if the runner trips running to first and is thrown out, it is just an out.

So if the fielder’s glove breaks, it is just a hit. Neither fielder did anything wrong. I’m leaning back towards “hit”.
 
Jul 5, 2019
5
3
Error. Its not changing the score of the game and I'm sure nobody of importance looks at a teams Game Changer. So the 1st baseman has an extra error at the end of the year. No biggie.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
42,865
Messages
680,371
Members
21,540
Latest member
fpmithi
Top