Catchers are in a unique position to get hit on the pelvic bone. Last year, our catcher took a bad hop to the pelvic bone that dropped her. She finished the game, but was really sore for several days.
Requiring some protection is a good thing, but there reaches a point when you're going out on the field like gladiators with so much equipment on. You can't protect kids from everything.
Agreed, but these little cups are small and slip into a pocket sewn into her sliding shorts, my daughter hardly notices wearing it. They aren't big and made of hard plastic like a guys cup is. My DD also wears here knee pads on her shins and a rip-it face mask when she is playing 3rd, so she can charge the ball or block a slide into base and not worry about shin or facial injuries (which she has had in the past.)
i am a HUGE fan of pelvic protectors. I think it shuld be mandated that every catcher wears one. The kind i have aren't uncomfortable. It will be uncomfortable at first, but that's just you are used to it. Now i walk around and when i go to sit criss-cross i always say "oh, i forgot i had my cup in". You barely even notice its there.
WSI WNS384 Women's Softball Sliding Short with Pelvic Protector - SportsAuthority.com
I think it's just not worth taking the chance of possibly seriously injuring yourself there. and as for the turtle shell bras, i've never heard of them but i will have to check them out.
Are they good fitting sliding shorts? I buy women's sliding shorts, without a pocket and the fit so much better. I'm not sure I'd be willing to wear that thing if the sliding shorts were uncomfortable. The women's are low rise, and the right length for me personally.