Sorry, as it was described, this is E8. As in most HS games sounds like most do not want the precious batting average to suffer but it sound like it should have been routine. I get into similar debates all of the time. Rule of thumb for me, if it seemed routine and the player should have made the play with minimal effort it is an error. My DD HS team has some of the more average batting averages in the county, and 8 state titles, and 18 state final 4 's. Funny how all of these .600 HS hitters go 0-4 vs us, then go off to college ball and wonder why they hit .235. Daddy stats is the answer in case you missed the sarcasim.