I'm telling you, the Akadema Praying Mantis APM66 is a 34.5" mitt that has ample room for my big (10.5" span) hand. And Akadema has a 50% off sale going with code HOLIDAY50 on their website. Ends up costing $57.50. It doesn't have the heaviest padding, but for a bucket dad it's a nice deal. At the price, it's the steal of the century.
APM66 Softball Glove; 34