Not sure how anybody could be happy with a coach who uses pick-up players and has his own players sit. I personally find that to be about as Bush League as it gets and also believe it is unethical to the point that I'd be aggressively shopping for a new team.
That coach has no interest in his girls. He's in it for himself.
I love the kids on our team. We aren't very good, but we play hard and are getting better. I am helping coach and we've got the players turned in the right direction and improving. Some of the parents (and grandparents are awful). One of the parents asked me why I was having them hit so many popups during the game. I told him next game we would give more line drive signs.
I'm not completely opposed to letting guests play more in some cases. We have a high school dark period in our state, so its a mad scramble to keep the 14U teams together during these months. If a coach lends me a couple of players as a courtesy, you bet I am going to treat them at least as equals on my team. It takes some management skill to do it right, but I think its the right thing to do. Now, if you are adding pickup players to an already large roster, I agree with Little Angels (unless it's the last qualifier .
Not happy with our choice at the moment. Coach just berated her for what seemed like 10 minutes in the middle of a game over an admittedly very boneheaded decision on Sunday. But this was after a game where she pitched us to a win by getting 8 Ks and giving up 2 hits. No mention of the good pitching after the win, but real quick to pull the trigger and call her stupid and dumb when she makes mistakes on D. DD is checked out now and does not want to play for him and wants to take a break for a few months, which I am fine with, but I want her to confront this situation and not just take her ball and go home. So we are sleeping on it for a few days while spring break is shutting everything down and we will figure it out next week when practice resumes.