I picked up an All-Star CMW3000 for less than $100 on a black Friday deal. I use it to catch softball and baseball pitchers. Soon, I'll hand it down to DD. Lots of protection. Well worth it at full price. Awesome glove.
https://www.all-starsports.com/cmw3000.html
Hi- I would go with a Rawlings Liberty Advanced 34” mitt. I have the Worth version and my daughter has the Rawlings all white model. Great gloves!!! A little stiff to start with but breaks in easy and plenty of padding!!! Also you can get 1 for around $100 if you shop around!!!I know this has been posted before but all the recommendations have been discontinued. I definitely don't have big hands but most of the fastpitch catcher mitts I have tried have been too tight in the opening and finger stalls.