I know this has been posted before but all the recommendations have been discontinued. I definitely don't have big hands but most of the fastpitch catcher mitts I have tried have been too tight in the opening and finger stalls.
With one DD pitching and the other DD catching I (luckily) don't have to do as much bucket time as some ogf you guys but when I do I've been reaching for the Liberty Advanced over her Vinci. Finger stalls are definitely a bit roomier.
I don't think I would ever choose white as a "game" glove - but I'm also not throwing it down in the dirt between innings.
I also don't think I have above average hand-size - finger stalls seem normal to me.
This series is usually one of the recommendations due to fitting a male hand easier, and also usually in the discussion for thumb protection.
I got it last fall, and after working on it for a few days, was able to use it in a "coaches" game later that week. Only had one ball pop out that I felt I would have caught with a full break-in.
I also paid less the than $159 that's on the link - maybe $110 with one of the coupons you get every other day from the online vendors.
I'll also add a plug for Vinci - I bought a baseball catchers mitt - instantly adds +10 mph to any pitch due to the great "pop" sound from the glove!
I bought a Rawlings Liberty Advanced 34 a few months ago and I have enormous hands, fits me fine now that it’s good and broke in. I will say the break in period was long..took a while, but it’s a great mitt for a dad.
I picked up an All-Star CMW3000 for less than $100 on a black Friday deal. I use it to catch softball and baseball pitchers. Soon, I'll hand it down to DD. Lots of protection. Well worth it at full price. Awesome glove.