Are you saying that for a hitter with limited ability and skill that the no-stride is better?
I believe a stride is important in creating rythem, timing, etc... that said the first thing I do with a new or "messed up" hitter is take the stride away. I have them load by lifting the stride leg heel towards the inside of the front foot and by turning or cocking the front knee in just a bit to load the rear leg. At the same time they move the hands back just a bit, and they launch by dropping the front heel. It solves some initial problems, lunging, bending the front knee, and it seems to give them a good base to start from. Then we can add a stride later on. Also I have them in a wider than normal stance to start with. Seems to work.
I know you werent asking me just thought I would add my thoughts.
Thanks
Mike
p.s I have added quite a few things to the arsenal since howard has been posting.