I recall seeing Cat in HS and her batting skills were, IMO definitely suboptimal. She was slow on the base paths and her fielding was not what I would call stellar. YMMV
I felt the same way when I saw Michael Jordon on the baseball field. Come to think of it he couldn't make the PGA tour either. That guy must have worked his rear off in basketball, he obviously didn't have any natural talent.
Before I get in trouble, I am not implying Cat is an athlete like Micheal Jordon. Just that some body types are good for some athletic activities and not others. There are very few that can do it all.