Runner to 1st with nobody on:
2nd base player is cut off for RF with throw to 2nd.
SS is cut off for CF and LF with throw to 2nd.
Runner at 1st with the potential to make it to 3rd.
2nd base is still cut for RF with throw to 3rd (she does not cut off as deep though)
SS is still the cut off for CF and LF.
My pitcher is the back up for most throws to 2nd and 3rd coming from out field.
If no possible way for play to be made at 1st, well 1st base better be headed to back up catcher. A good runner on 1st with hit over the outfielders will go home (on my team better be).
What you are advocating is a typical cutoff scenario for 10U-12U players. (asked by Steve Huff)
As I am a middle school/JV coach with limited amount of student body to work with. Of course I should have stated I was referring to young kids.