I won't try and speculate as to the reasons for what happened. That said, I will let you know how I, as a coach, treat my pick-ups/subs. I treat them as I would any other member of my team. In other words, every player will sit 2 innings during a pool play game and be on the field the rest of the time. The same holds true for my pick-ups. First, I want them to want to come back and play again if I need them. Second, none of my parents will complain since everyone's playing, being treated fairly and they understand the need.
Please understand that when I use a sub, I'm doing it to fill a specific spot or position than I'm in need of. For example, say I need a SS for a tournament. I happen to pick up a Flamethrower who also plays SS. Because I have 3 pitchers already, guess how many innings this sub is going to pitch? I'll tell you the exact number...0-1 in a weekend. I don't care if she's going to the Florida Gators as a Pitcher on a full ride no matter how tempting it would become. Why you may ask? Because it's not worth the headaches it will cause among the team, my pitchers and my parents even if we rode this Flamethrower and won the entire thing. More importantly, I wouldn't have her beyond the weekend and it's not fair to my 3 pitchers I made my commitment to when they committed to me. Loyalty to the players you have can be easily underrated but is so important.
The next thing to discuss is a tryout/sub situation such as your DD faced. If I'm trying a player out, once again, I'm trying them out for a need to fill a specific position. In your DD's case, both you and her may feel her primary position is a Catcher but she also plays the corners and outfield. I currently have 5 "Catchers" on my team. 1 is truly a Catcher and will be moving on to play in college. Another is a work in progress but coming along. The other 3 have the gear and I can put them behind the plate in a pinch but all they can do is catch a pitch and nothing else. The one thing they all had in common is they felt their primary position was Catcher. So when I offered the last 3, I told them flat out they will not be behind the plate except in the possibility of an extreme emergency but I saw them playing position X if they wanted it. So in your DD's case, if she were to sub/try out for me, I would be looking for example, a corner player or OFer which is where she'd play during the tourney. That doesn't mean that she would not be given the chance to work her way into the line-up as a catcher. However, for my team, her primary position would be third base for example (if she were offered)... not a catcher. Thus, if she were to come and tryout/sub for a tourney with us, the chances of her getting behind the plate for more than an inning would be slim.
Please understand that when I use a sub, I'm doing it to fill a specific spot or position than I'm in need of. For example, say I need a SS for a tournament. I happen to pick up a Flamethrower who also plays SS. Because I have 3 pitchers already, guess how many innings this sub is going to pitch? I'll tell you the exact number...0-1 in a weekend. I don't care if she's going to the Florida Gators as a Pitcher on a full ride no matter how tempting it would become. Why you may ask? Because it's not worth the headaches it will cause among the team, my pitchers and my parents even if we rode this Flamethrower and won the entire thing. More importantly, I wouldn't have her beyond the weekend and it's not fair to my 3 pitchers I made my commitment to when they committed to me. Loyalty to the players you have can be easily underrated but is so important.
The next thing to discuss is a tryout/sub situation such as your DD faced. If I'm trying a player out, once again, I'm trying them out for a need to fill a specific position. In your DD's case, both you and her may feel her primary position is a Catcher but she also plays the corners and outfield. I currently have 5 "Catchers" on my team. 1 is truly a Catcher and will be moving on to play in college. Another is a work in progress but coming along. The other 3 have the gear and I can put them behind the plate in a pinch but all they can do is catch a pitch and nothing else. The one thing they all had in common is they felt their primary position was Catcher. So when I offered the last 3, I told them flat out they will not be behind the plate except in the possibility of an extreme emergency but I saw them playing position X if they wanted it. So in your DD's case, if she were to sub/try out for me, I would be looking for example, a corner player or OFer which is where she'd play during the tourney. That doesn't mean that she would not be given the chance to work her way into the line-up as a catcher. However, for my team, her primary position would be third base for example (if she were offered)... not a catcher. Thus, if she were to come and tryout/sub for a tourney with us, the chances of her getting behind the plate for more than an inning would be slim.
Last edited:
