I watched catcher #2 last night, give me catcher #1 please!
How's the pitching on the team? If it's questionable to crappy, Catcher 1 for sure!
Good pitching but their #1 pitcher is a drop ball pitcher so she does get some balls in the dirt.
I'd want the one who blocks best. Even with good pitching. The weaker arm may give up more 2B steals but when there's a runner on 3 and a catcher who can't block well, you give up runs and not just bases. JMO.
If we are going to play this game, we have pitchers with really good control so we want Catcher 3: High receiving, big arm, lesser blocking skills.
Receiving gives more strike and outs. To me it is the most critical skill. If there are less runners on base, then the other two skills matter less
Big arm is second. If they do get on, I want the scared to take risks on the base and if they do, I want them to pay
Blocking is third... Eh, I give up a base every now and then IF they are on and IF they haven't already been caught stealing/picked off. Also even on a semi-decent block, if they had a limited lead (because of the big arm), you get a few more close plays.