Coogan--there is no question the kid (16YOA) did not play well. She really did self-destruct. If she continues to do this, she will lose her role on the team. A coach should ask what is going on and if there was anything that might need to be adjusted. The discussions would be in private and at least a day or two later.
I understand. I was just commenting on the way you worded it. After a performance like that, I think saying ''you need to pitch better when the game is on the line'' is not the most helpful thing because it states the obvious and also can be interpreted as 'you let us down.' I think it's better to problem solve, kinda like you're saying above. I think the message should be ''we're in this together, what can we do to play better in these situations.''