here are 2 scenarios that were presented to me. Looking for some feedback from the experts on here. This is school ball so NFHS/ASA rules
1. Put Hannah in lineup as DP in 6th spot in order for example. List Kayla as 9/Flex in 10th spot. Basically Kayla plays defense and hannah hits. Kayla can run for Hannah if needed but only 1 time due to rentry rule for Hannah. If she runs twice, can Kayla just stay in lineup as RF and hit in the 6th spot? Or do I need a new hitting in 6th spot bc Hannah is out due to reentry.
2. List Hannah as RF only. If I want to put Kayla in for defense later in game then it would be a straight substitution. Kayla in - Hannah out with potential re-entry. Is there a way to be able to switch Kayla in for defense later in game but not lose Hannah in batting order? List Hannah as DP/9? Still list Kayla as Flex? Then Kayla can play defense for anyone as flex, correct? But if she is listed as Flex in the 10 spot on the lineup does she have to be in the game to start?
#1, you can switch back and forth between 10 and 9 players as many times as you want and have available subs to fill whichever position you have leaving the lineup. The second time you had the flex run for the dp, yes that particular dp could no longer come back into the game, but any available legal sub could come in and take the dp position. There is no requirement to put another dp into the game, if you had the flex run for the dp a second time and the original dp no longer had a re-entry, yes the flex can just continue to occupy that spot in the batting order for the remainder of the game and leave the lineup at 9 players.
#2, Im not completely following what you are trying to do. The dp is an offensive position that can also play defense for any player other than the flex and no one has left the game. The flex is a defensive position only and must be on the field. If Im following what you are trying to do, it is the dp, not the flex that can be moved around on defense and play for other positions. The flex must be out on defense or they have left the game. The dp/flex option must be on the lineup card at when they are submitted to the umpire, but, the coach can immediately drop to 9 players after that and still have the dp/flex option available for the remainder of the game.