A different kind of "proud of her" moment...

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

Jun 20, 2012
438
18
SoCal
DD2 just completed her first year of travel and is entering her second year of 12u. Towards the end of the last season, she told us that she wanted to tryout for other teams. I thought it was just a phase she was going through and maybe she was a bit tired of her teammates at that point after spending almost every spare moment with them for the past 11 months, and that once she's had some time away she'd be refreshed and ready to get back with her friends. Besides, she had an almost ideal situation on her team: she was constantly in contention for #1 pitcher innings, played her second favorite position when she wasn't pitching, and was among the top 3 batters on her team, almost always batting 3, 4, or 5. The head coach really liked her and she really liked her teammates. Sure, the team lost far more often than they won, and most of her teammates failed to progress as much as she did over the course of the year, but we were happy and appreciated the experience she was getting and the families got along very well. That should be good, right?

Well, something happened along the way. In late June, she picked-up with a team for a week-long tournament, and this team was on a whole different level. She was no longer the big fish in the little pond. Most of that team was 2nd-year 12's and she looked like a little girl among women with them. They practiced and played with a different level of focus and determination than she was accustomed to. The whole time leading up to this tournament I was constantly having the "don't be upset if you don't play, remember, you're just a pick-up player, be ready to play at a moment's notice, but also remain positive even if you don't play" conversation with her. Well, we get out there, and after a semi-rough first day, she saw far more playing time than I expected, either in the circle or as DP. She played at a level I hadn't seen out of her, ever.

When we returned, I was excited to see her carry it over to her team. Instead, she returned to being the player she was before. She'd have her moments, but wouldn't sustain that level of focus and intensity. As the season came to a close, she repeated her desire to tryout with other teams. So we took her to a few tryouts, and part of me was hoping she wouldn't get an offer anywhere else. Instead, she got offered spots on every team she tried out for. Even then, I didn't think she'd ever leave. She didn't even want to tryout for travel in the first place, and I thought that she was very comfortable where she was at and when the reality of leaving her comfort zone hit, she would prefer to remain where she was. Boy was I wrong.

The day after her second callback with a team, she came to DW and me with tears in her eyes and told us she decided she felt she needed to move on to this other team. She said she was crying because she was going to miss her teammates, but that she felt that she needed to go to a team where she would have to work to get playing time, and that she really liked the level that this other team played at.

I didn't know what to say or how to respond. She, at 11 years old, was brave enough to make the decision that I didn't want to make. She surprised us with the maturity and thought she put into this decision. I pushed back a little, but she held firm in her decision, all the while fighting back the tears and the pain she was feeling of leaving her teammates behind.

I'm so proud of her.
 
May 24, 2013
12,461
113
So Cal
Awesome story, CPEM!

There are some players where being on a team with friends or with a familiar coach is the most important factor to them - sometimes it's born out of fear of leaving their comfortable old box There are also players who want to see just how good they can be. It sounds like she got a chance to see that there is a whole new level of development available to her, and she realized she wouldn't be able to reach with the old team. Props to you for giving her the freedom to make the choice for herself and the opportunity to follow her own dreams. I hope she has a great time! :)
 
May 15, 2016
926
18
As Eric F said, awesome story.

My DD1's head coach told me privately that she and her sister stayed on a lesser team because they wanted to stay with their friends, and they both regretted it ever since. She said they probably could have gone further with their softball career if they moved up to a better team. Sounds like your DD is clearly headed in the right direction.
 
May 24, 2013
12,461
113
So Cal
One thing to keep attentive to is playing time. If she's still getting lots of playing time on the better team, that's great. If she's spending more time on the bench, it might not be the right fit.
 
Nov 29, 2009
2,975
83
It sounds like your DD is a smart girl. She understands the biggest detriment to a player's development in any sport can be friends. She wants to play with like-minded and competitive girls. Kudos to her for understanding a true friend will be that, no matter what team she plays for. If her friends are no longer her friends because of the team she chooses to play on they were never her friends.
 
Jun 19, 2013
753
28
My DD made a similar decision at that age to leave the team where she was a big fish and go become a little fish and learn a lot. And even though she didn't play a ton it was a good place for her for a year to glean from those coaches. I remember after the tryout and offer and her saying "well mom I like these other girls and it's pretty fun but I think if I ever wanna be really good I better go now and learn a lot". And I was just sitting there like a deer in the headlights. It's cool when they step up like that for the first time and make a big decision.
 
Oct 21, 2016
189
28
Really great story that almost mirrors my DD this summer. My DD was a top 3 hitter on her team and #1 C as a first year TB player at 12U this past season, but the team was mediocre mainly due to to lack of pitching. It was a first year team and DD was a team leader statistically and really got along with the girls, but she picked up with a couple better teams for Nationals at years end I saw a different level of focus, effort, and outcomes playing with better girls against better competition. When it came time to decide whether to leave or stay, it wasn't easy. The biggest factor for me was I knew she would be happy if she stayed, and leaving was full of unknowns. With so many teams in-fighting and disbanding every year, including ones in our organization, and friends of hers unhappy on other teams due to mean girls, bad coaching, and you name it, I will admit I lost sleep over the decision. Complicating things even more is that I'm an AC on her team, and most likely meant not being on the field with DD again, maybe ever. In the end it was her decision, and she decided to stay, and I'm content because I know she will be happy for another year playing the game she loves with a group of girls she really likes, but I don't know if it was the best decision for her development as a player, but maybe that's OK.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
42,862
Messages
680,325
Members
21,534
Latest member
Kbeagles
Top