Catcher 1 - Great receiving, but has an arm injury, and can't throw to any base.
Catcher 2 - Spotty receiving, with multiple passed balls per game, but has a strong arm.
Which one do you put behind the plate?
^^^^this you could get away with it for a little while but if they found out I'm not a real fan of every base hit turning into a triple.Think it matters if the other team knows catcher 1 can't throw. If they don't know use catcher 1 until they figure it out. She can fake it for while. Say runner takes off, she purposely lets it bounce out of her glove and just eats it and doesn't throw.