I know this is an expensive option, but Rawlings black dry horween, their black oiled horween, or their black Japanese tanned (J-Tan) leathers are awesome, especially their customs, very thick, tough, and durable steer hide! Now having said that, I've never had a custom Rawlings fastpitch catchers mitt in my hands, I basing that on their custom fielders gloves. But I can't imagine their mitts would be any different.
Now that I think about it, a while back a board member posted a custom Rawlings mitt here, it was blue......I *think*?
Now that I think about it, a while back a board member posted a custom Rawlings mitt here, it was blue......I *think*?