Vinci JCV34. Best padding available. She won't need another mitt for the rest of her college career.
See, I've been really intrigued by the Vinci's but have never seen one in person. My biggest problem is we don't have any stores that carry a good selection of quality catchers gloves for her to try. I don't think DH will like the credit card bill after I order 2 or 3 gloves for her to test.