My daughter uses the Mizuno Helmet. It fits her well. We like the matte finish. The Mizuno fit better than some of the other helmets on her. For her next helmet, I would probably buy a Schutt. I saw one at a baseball/softball specialty store recently. The quality is good and domestically made.
I've tried a few on but Rip-It was my favorite. It was the lightest and had a spot for my ponytail and the memory foam made it comfortable and it fit perfectly. They also use this thing called black out technology that helps eliminate glare without eyeblack so this is definitely my number 1 choice