My DD is very similar to Eric's DD in that she didn't like the fit of the All-Star. She used one for about two years and was constantly messing with it. The favorite that she's tried on was also the Pro-X. We ended up purchasing a Jen Shro mask thinking it'd be very similar to the Pro-X. The fit wasn't quite the same and she doesn't like it as much. The moisture wicking covering on the padding on the inside came out on it as well.