I disagree China. This was the first year our team used the evaluation forms and I found sharing the information to be VERY helpful when it came to making the decisions. I hate making cuts on a team more than I can put into words, but I took the time to provide scores to each parent for their player. Most were very understanding and appreciated the feedback in identifying areas to work on. Sure there are going to be those that won't listen to you because they think their daughter is a mega superstar and any team should be honored to have them on their roster. But do you really want those kind of parents involved with your program anyway??
The scorecard method is not perfect but we will be using it from now on as it is way better than nothing.
The scorecard method is not perfect but we will be using it from now on as it is way better than nothing.