Trick question! A good batting stance will be an athletic position, meaning that they would already be on the balls of their feet. As they explode lower body the toe ends up pointing to where the contact point with the ball will be, and yes the back heel will follow their toe or else they will have physical issues, and would come up to nearly a vertical during that rotation. For an inside pitch the back toe would end up facing directly towards the pitcher, but for an outside pitch the contact would be made with that toe pointing toward first base lets say.Also, does the back toe rotate towards the pitcher throughout the swing and end up on the ball of the foot?
The visual is probably the easiest way to explain it. If there was a really big hairy spider under the ball of your back foot you would both rotate that back foot and drive down your weight down through it to ensure that it was dead the first time. I can assure anyone with PETA that no bugs were injured during that illustration. When you finished the seam in your back leg would be running straight up and down, and both your calf and thigh would be bulging. Others will answer the second half of the question as to why they think it's wrong.Can someone tell us their definition of "squishing the bug"?
Although I am guilty of teaching it in the past, the bat behind the back definately encourages keeping weight on the back leg instead of transfering it.
that drill is meant to encourage rotation of the hips and is good for that purpose
if your back toe doesn't spin your hips haven't rotated while u swing - the toe has to rotate
Maybe I am getting to old for the squish the bug explanations anymore! If it were acceptable you would see the big boys and girls using it that make millions of dollars!
I happened to know to go find pictures of him, because he's one of the featured players in Right View Pro and is the classic example of what I teach. It's easy to say I'm old fashioned for using the "forbidden" term "squish the bug" to keep things simple and give girls a visual, but it's hard to argue with his success. I do teach girls to both load and stride, so no that video isn't of me.