Find the best pitcher and offer her dad an AC job. Then draft the second best pitcher.
You will have less compitition in your league if you have the top 2 pitchers on your team. Not sure how big your league is but in our rec league we have 6 12U teams and we only play with in our league so to avoid a top heavy team our pitchers are paired so top ranked pitchers get paired with lowest ranked pitcher, (1-12, 2-11...6-7)