When you look at higher-level D1 teams, the best ones (those in the Top 25, say) have a fielding percentage of .960 or better. The very best teams (e.g., Oklahoma) consistently have fielding percentages of .980+. They make mistakes, which are part of the game, but not very many. I'd say the magic number of .960+ is a defensive standard that should be aimed for once you get past the developmental levels. Extra outs and free bases are definitely a sure way to lose to comparably or higher skilled teams.
In the small circles I run in, I see near maniacal focus on hitting but very little on individual defensive skills (outside of pitcher + catcher). Part of it is that defensive practice is likely to require mom or dad or somebody to hit decent fungo and to have an adequate outdoor or indoor space to do it.
In the small circles I run in, I see near maniacal focus on hitting but very little on individual defensive skills (outside of pitcher + catcher). Part of it is that defensive practice is likely to require mom or dad or somebody to hit decent fungo and to have an adequate outdoor or indoor space to do it.