If there is clear direction, please cite the NFHS softball rule to which the clear direction applies. If you are attempting to apply rule 6-2-2, you are incorrect. Rule 6-2-2 specifically states that dirt is NOT considered a foreign substance. Therefore applying dirt to the ball is not illegal. I am still waiting for someone to name the rule that actually states "players shall not apply dirt to the ball". In their 2024 Softball Rules Interpretations, NFHS incorrectly issued an interpretation of a phantom rule.First there is 100% clear direction on this call. There is no discussion to be had other than how the rules committee has decided it is to be called. Not sure what you don't understand about that. Case books/scenarios are directives on how to interpret and call situations - they are not up for local OR personal feelings discussion. It is how it is to be called.
Second, as I stated above, while they recognized the rule break, they failed to apply the penalty immediately. You can't let the pitch happen - there is no reason for it. It isn't a delayed dead ball and they still have to pitch.
Also, the delayed dead ball signal IS specified for rule 6-2-2.