DD prefers the Schutt. Chin cup is more comfortable, and seems to stay attached better. Kept losing the RipIt chin cup. The quality of the mask construction appears to be better to my layman's eye. Also like that you can remove the forehead pad and wash it.
DD12 had the original Rip-it and hated wearing it. She said the bars were too close to her nose and she didn't like how the chin cup felt. Got her the Schutt and she has zero complaints wearing it. Never had the chin cup fall of the Schutt yet and we've had it almost a year.