Confusion on ASA ruling on blocking home plate

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

Strike2

Allergic to BS
Nov 14, 2014
2,054
113
Okay this comes up over and over and over again. And I see outs constantly lost because catchers are standing in front of the plate and they catch the ball and try to reach back and tag.

What is the 2017 best practice for positioning a catcher to receive a throw? I know what the 1960 one is and it doesn't look like it works to me. NECC people let's hear it!

I use what was taught to me as a kid by a coach who was a pro catcher in the 1960s, and still see used today. I teach them to start with their left heel on the corner of the plate closest to 3B. That leaves the runner access to the back half before the ball is caught and greatly reduces the chances of the runner getting between the ball and the catcher. The catcher is now in good position to adjust up the 3B line, if necessary, to grab an errant throw. After receiving the throw, the catcher then pushes the tag into the runner's path. Assuming a decent throw, they're in a strong athletic position and well protected. Not a big reach to the tag, especially for older players.
 
Jun 22, 2008
3,757
113
Malicious contact in NFHS is malicious regardless of who does it. If the offense does it, they are out and could be ejected. No way to call the defense out, so they can receive a warning or ejection for the contact.

The video you posted is from 2-3 years ago. I was able to pull the whole game up on NFHS Network and watch it. In my opinion the umpires never had any control through the entire game. There was a questionable play at 2nd that never received any attention and there was a play at the plate earlier in the game where the runner coming home did a full body cross block on the catcher who was 3' up the line attempting to throw to 1st base. Every one of the situations in the game were done by the same team as the catcher in the video. Kind of hard to believe it was not being purposely coached with that many instances all by the same team in the same game.
 
Jun 16, 2017
3
0
Malicious contact in NFHS is malicious regardless of who does it. If the offense does it, they are out and could be ejected. No way to call the defense out, so they can receive a warning or ejection for the contact.

The video you posted is from 2-3 years ago. I was able to pull the whole game up on NFHS Network and watch it. In my opinion the umpires never had any control through the entire game. There was a questionable play at 2nd that never received any attention and there was a play at the plate earlier in the game where the runner coming home did a full body cross block on the catcher who was 3' up the line attempting to throw to 1st base. Every one of the situations in the game were done by the same team as the catcher in the video. Kind of hard to believe it was not being purposely coached with that many instances all by the same team in the same game.

That is why these rules need to be understood and enforced correctly. Many coaches will not make adjustments unless their players start getting called on it.
 
Aug 24, 2011
161
0
I use what was taught to me as a kid by a coach who was a pro catcher in the 1960s, and still see used today. I teach them to start with their left heel on the corner of the plate closest to 3B. That leaves the runner access to the back half before the ball is caught and greatly reduces the chances of the runner getting between the ball and the catcher. The catcher is now in good position to adjust up the 3B line, if necessary, to grab an errant throw. After receiving the throw, the catcher then pushes the tag into the runner's path. Assuming a decent throw, they're in a strong athletic position and well protected. Not a big reach to the tag, especially for older players.

This is the best way to do it. As I'm sure you instruct, make sure the catcher's kneecap is pointed up the line and not to the side as the knee is most vulnerable from the side. It has to be repped though because it's more natural for catchers to turn their knee.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
42,857
Messages
680,278
Members
21,525
Latest member
Go_Ask_Mom
Top