My answer comes from being involved as a manager, coach, administrator for nearly 15 years.
The most important thing to remember first is that this is a game and we are here for the kids. In the natural course of softball or other sports, there are so many varieties of players, administrators...
First, increase your rating range to at least 5. I use a 1-10 system (league gave me a 1-5 sheet that they use). Second, be honest. If the kid is a stud, indicate that with your answers. If the kid is bad, give 1's. Be honest. Also, give them enough good reps to show what they can do.
A draft...
The ASA has nothing to do with the Little League rule book. What the book does say is that a player MUST have played in 60% of the season's regular season schedule. They could apply any games played for school to the games on the schedule that a player may have missed because of school team...