- Feb 12, 2014
- 648
- 43
While I like Gamechanger stats, they are only as good as the person entering the data which most of the time is entered by marginally educated scorekeepers. For example, the hard hit ball (HHB) is either a line drive or hard hit ground ball. Can a typical mom/dad scorekeeper really tell the difference and are they being consistent among teammates, other team batters, etc? And with errors vs. hits stats its wildly inaccurate. For example, after one rec season (16 games), several teams had ZERO Reached on Error (ROE) stats for any player! Conversely, their teams batting average was over .400! (no surprise there).
As I mentioned above, stats are only as good as the scorekeeper. However, I do think there are some great parent scorekeepers out there. I know that I probably error on being too tough on my DD. Only real softball-related fight my wife and I ever have gotten in was over a scorekeeping decision I made for DD.
To me, the hard hit ball is tough. What is hard hit for one kid may not be for another. Sometimes, I'll have the girls on the bench with me decide. That's fun and keeps them in the game (I do, from time to time, overrule them). But, unless you have access to exit velocity stats, hard hit balls are always going to be subjective even for professional scorekeepers.