This is a good post. I recently just went thru this same thing. My 10u pitchers moved up to 12u for the fall. Now my #1 pitcher must play 12u my #2 pitcher can still play 10u(but hoping to move her with rest of team). We were playing a fall ball game and my #1 was pitching ok not her best but just OK. Now my team behind her was NOT helping 1 bit. So after a 7 run 1st inning I pulled the #1 for the #2. After the games were over #1s Dad tells me Im destroying her confidence and that I was more concerned about winning then developing. First off its fall it means nothing in the 12u world. I know what the #1 pitcher has and I certainly dont need to see her on the field getting her brains beat in when she has no supporting cast behind her. Now on the other hand I need to see the #2 in those conditions. I need to know that at the older age level se can get out of it on her own. I need to see if she can make the pitches needed to get out of it on her own. So for him and his accusations it was rediculous. Sometimes parents have no clue as to what is going on. IT ALWAYS DADDY GLASSES ON and my princess can do no wrong.
On a side note last summer #1 was not the #1. She couldnt throw a strike if home plate was 3 ft wide. We did alot of work in the off season to get her straightened out. Also worked on her being tougher mentally. So by me pulling her was saving what we had fixed over the winter. This most recent summer she threw 38.1 innings for me and had 99ks and 46bb.
On a side note last summer #1 was not the #1. She couldnt throw a strike if home plate was 3 ft wide. We did alot of work in the off season to get her straightened out. Also worked on her being tougher mentally. So by me pulling her was saving what we had fixed over the winter. This most recent summer she threw 38.1 innings for me and had 99ks and 46bb.