Something seems to have changed, especially at those high academic schools. The admissions offices seem much more fully in charge, and decisions are coming much later.
DD visited a very elite D3 school and met with the coach who had seen her play a couple of times and had phone conversations with. DD asked specifically if the coach had any pull with admissions if she had the Test scores and GPA for the school. The answer was no and even though she had a 33 ACT would she be taking it again to see if she could up her score?
DD has a number of D3s on her list. It wasn't until her this year (17' grad) that they started indicating they'd come look at her.