I figured I'd update one last time! After many doctors visits, we came across the problem. I had torn my labrum, the tissue keeping the "ball and socket" together. This tear required surgery, which I had on the 28th of May, and am currently in the recovery/rehab stage. My surgeon suspected that the tear had been from overhand throwing and WAS NOT a recent injury, due to the amount of scar tissue built up. For now, I'm focusing on rehab and getting back to where I was, pre surgery. We are still unsure about a future softball career but we are praying. Thank you all for your help and input, as well as best wishes, it was all greatly appreciated! Kelly