Well yes. Best players on the diamond.
Not sure I agree with that...I think the players from the team should get the most playing time because it is their team. They have worked all season, mom and dad have paid, and I believe that is the fair thing to do. A pick-up should and has to play, but in relief more or less. DD picks up and and expects to sit more than normal before we head out. Now, you cannot let them sit there for the "just in case injury" occurs, but shorting your own players to put a pick up out there is wrong to me.
Some parents remember from 8U or 10U that RF was where you hide kids.
DD is a starting catcher and plays OF when not catching. She is very proud of the fact she can cover 20-25yds to run down a fly. In the circles we play in there are a lot of balls hit to OF. There are throw downs to that must be backed up and knowing where to go with runners on base is very important. A two second hold of the ball trying to determine where to throw means another base for runners. When you think about all the defensive plays the OF is involved with the spot becomes much more important. Someone here posted a laundry list of things HS outfielders should know and be able to perform. It's much more than say fist base. Without a good OF you are toast.
IF your parents think it is a punishment, the position is probably not being played right and their kid is just standing there.
This I totally agree with. It is too bad so many parents (and kids) equate OF with punishment. It could be because too many coaches use that as a punishment (DD had one). There is a person who posts here that had a great comment on this the other day. He/She asked their team which position they were not going to play on a certain day. Once they said you had to have all of them, he promtply illustrated the point that all positions are important. DD played MI for a long time and has transitioned to outfield because she covers a lot of ground and likes it more now. Playing OF has an appropriate skill set that I think too many coaches do not focus on.
This was 16U team and we were playing in an 18U tournament.
Wow. That's borderline sociopathic behavior. We'll be seeing that family on Jerry Springer one day. My kid would have not seen a softball field for a long time (if ever) with a stunt like that. Although imagining the looks of dismay on everybody's face is making me chuckle a little bit.