DD has the under armour, she loves it. My husband sometimes drives like a crazy person and he's never made it leak. (DD is really good about keeping the latch locked down.)
We had really bad luck with DD's Under Armour. Handle broke in the dugout when it got knocked off the bench. The top is either never latched, or it pops with a roll around the floorboard.
We got our dd the Rtic 64 and also the Wild Wolf Outfitters 64 jug holder (helps out with the dugout dust ,dirt, etc) has storage pockets for cell phones etc , she just clips it to her gear bag .
RTIC in the half/gallon sizes... on sale also and will keep ice for weeks at a time. Had a tourney two weeks ago and went to refill jug for this weekend, still had ice in it. I was amazed.
I use a Hydroflask water bottle and I've had absolutely no complaints about it not keeping water cold most of the day. I love mine. Mine, however, has gotten pretty beat up and I may look into replacing it and the RTIC jugs you guys have been talking about seem pretty interesting.