Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

Register Log in

either out or not


Jun 22, 2008
Good info. You make the bang-bang call as much with your hearing at first as you do with your eyes. At umpire school they actually do a drill with you making the call blindfolded using hearing alone.
While that is a nice exercise, but not a fan of it being taught. Different sounds from the same source is very possible and vice versa. I've often seen a player catch a throw to a base with little to no audible sound. Same with a BR touching 1B.

Sounds can be helpful, but shouldn't become a standard part of the umpire's standard decision making process.

I am not saying it should not be used as it can be very helpful. I have used it a few times. The most notable was in a World Cup game in Plant City, FL Runner trying to stretch a deuce into a triple and the throw from left center was wide (2B side of 3rd). The infielder caught the ball and made a desperate swing trying to tag the runner diving into 3B. I never saw a definitive tag, but I heard the glove catch the cleats of the runner. I called the out on the evidence I had available.

Members online

Latest threads

Forum statistics

Latest member