Fixing a Segmented Swing and a flat lead elbow...?'s

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

Mar 2, 2018
88
0
Drodd dont you know chappy isnt a turn the barrel guy? Hes a hammer down guy. No way hed agree with what your saying I guarantee it.
 
Mar 2, 2018
88
0
Your trigger is turning the barrel with the hands and that puts the hands ahead of everything. Stretch is just released without any effort to release it? The hands tell the stretch to release? You have no whip to hit with. Im gonna tell you again against good pitching your toast.

In all fairness to you I think your trying to explain something you dont understand.
 
Last edited:
Feb 16, 2015
933
43
South East
Interesting... Using TTB as the trigger sounds very close to HI to me, but maybe Buttermaker or Spartans can correct me. I was raised as a "hands" hitter from when I was young (long before I joined any of the forums), so there are aspects of Chappy's stuff that I find interesting. It just resonates with stuff my mentors talked about. Thanks for the discussion DRDRODD. Good stuff...

Yea it does that is why I wrote flattening & torquing also, different strokes for different folks. I was trying to use the terminology that people on this forum are used to. I view turning the barrel as a flatting process to get on plane before the release. IMO there is no dying that the barrel is arching while this is taking place so I see where Turning the Barrel also makes sense. Isn't the stretching process the storing of kinetic energy? That is ultimately the point I am trying to make the body will support the role of the hands. When the brain tells the hands to smoke the ball, the hands will change the direction of the barrel and the body knows to release the stored energy.
 
Last edited:
Jul 16, 2013
4,659
113
Pennsylvania
Yea it does that is why I wrote flattening & torquing also, different strokes for different folks. I was trying to use the terminology that people on this forum are used to. I view turning the barrel as a flatting process to get on plane before the release. IMO there is no dying that the barrel is arching while this is taking place so I see where Turning the Barrel also makes sense. Isn't the stretching process the storing of kinetic energy? That is ultimately the point I am trying to make the body will support the role of the hands. When the brain tells the hands to smoke the ball, the hands will change the direction of the barrel and the body knows to release the stored energy.

By flattening and torquing, are you referring to a "running start"?
 
Feb 16, 2015
933
43
South East
By flattening and torquing, are you referring to a "running start"?

Maybe.... I am not that familiar with what is deemed a running start. I read what Tweks referred it as in his ebook and from his description and the pics of the roller coaster lol it would probably be safe to say that.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Jun 6, 2016
2,724
113
Chicago
The video is just talking about the slack removal process aka "walking away from the hands" or what ever other term people use to describe that.

Let me try and describe the trigger analogy again. The video showed JR walking away from the hands or pulling back with the scap how ever you want to look at it. He is removing the slack in his body. During this time he is also resisting with his pelvis as his rear leg is turning inward aka "coiling". This creates a rag ring affect in the rear Hip Joint Socket (coiling/loading). When he decides to launch his swing his hands start to turn the barrel, apply torque to the handle or start to flatten the barrel depending on how you look at it but the important thing is the direction that the bat is arcing. The barrel is arching away from lets say Right Center for a RH hitter and Left Center for a LH hitter. While this arcing is taking place the stretch throughout the body is still increasing due to the direction of the arcing. When the hands decide to turn the barrel into the ball " The Trigger" the stretch that was created is released without any conscience effort from the hitter "Gets Fired". I know that this probably doesn't make any sense to you what so ever but that is the best way I can describe it. The stretch is released when the hands tell it to be released.

OK, I think I get what you mean by the hands being the trigger now. I'm not sure if I agree or disagree; I truly don't know enough to have an opinion on this. It wasn't what I originally thought you meant though.

I'm assuming you've seen that Donaldson MLB Network piece where he dissects his swing. I think you disagree with his view on the role of the hands, right? Again, not trying to prove you wrong or anything. I truly am just trying to learn where everybody's coming from.
 
Feb 16, 2015
933
43
South East
OK, I think I get what you mean by the hands being the trigger now. I'm not sure if I agree or disagree; I truly don't know enough to have an opinion on this. It wasn't what I originally thought you meant though.

I'm assuming you've seen that Donaldson MLB Network piece where he dissects his swing. I think you disagree with his view on the role of the hands, right? Again, not trying to prove you wrong or anything. I truly am just trying to learn where everybody's coming from.

I am assuming that you are referring to how he says that he doesn't think of his hands........ I do not necessarily disagree with that but bringing the barrel to the ball is the thought process. No matter what anyone believes the hands are responsible for turning the bat at least 90 degrees of the 180 degree arc. What I have been referring to is how he states that he gets into his hip but he never mentions anything about firing his hip (if I remember correctly been a while since I have watched the video). Regardless how he believes he gets his initial bat speed (he sates his shoulders which I believe he is talking about using his core to speed up his shoulders) the hip stays loaded until his hands decide to release the barrel or turn it that 90 degrees.

IMO the best way to see that the hands trigger the hip firing is on off speed pitches when they get the front foot down early. They stay loaded in the hip until the hands tell it to fire (reactive). I do not see how someone can sit on an off speed pitch and think fire the hips and then fire the hands it would be way to slow. I would like to see video of Donaldson sitting on an off speed pitch just like Griffey & Bonds were so good at.
 
Last edited:
Jun 17, 2009
15,037
0
Portland, OR
I tell my hitters that the lead side gets to pulling as the rear side gets to throwing.

If you embrace how the lead side pulls, then you'll have the 'flattening' process as the barrel is 'worked/arc'd/orbited'.
 
Mar 2, 2018
88
0
The hands absolutely must not fire before the hips. Fiveframe I think you agree with this. The turning of the barrel is more of an arms action. Focusing on any barrel turning with the hands is what will slow down the swing bigtime. Doing that is a mistake and will get the hitter beat with good pitching every time they face it.
 
Mar 2, 2018
88
0
Any time the top half gets ahead of the lower half against decent pitching the hitter can just go sit back down in the dugout. Thats a fact.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
42,865
Messages
680,327
Members
21,523
Latest member
Brkou812
Top