No, sorry I must have misunderstood. I was talking about the Rawlings Liberty I linked in the first post. I looked at the All-Star, I was curious if there is a difference between a baseball vs softball difference. I will have her try the liberty when it arrives and go from there.
My only concern would have been with the hand stall size with your 11 year old, even though they’re both 13” gloves. As far as a 12” softball working with that baseball glove.......it would with absolutely no problem!
With those two gloves being only a $4.00 difference, I would have bought the All-Star just to check it out and return it if there was a issue. I can promise you, there’s NO comparison between those two gloves!! That Maruhashi leather is the real deal!