If she has small hands, in my extremely biased opinion, you owe it to her to get a glove from Bradley and see how it fits her hand. He offers a 30 day, no questions asked, return policy (I've seen some of the gloves he's refunded, and he really means no questions asked). If it doesn't fit her hand really well, you just send it back. I think she will be really happy with the fit, and I think you'll be really happy with the quality of the leather once you get your hands on it.
My DD doesn't like the velcro so she uses the regular Bandito and Next Play series but she has the FP Gold catcher's mitt and I can verify that the quality of the FP series gloves are just as good as the "baseball" gloves. DD and DS virtually live in their gloves, they like them so much.