Thanks everyone! I think I'm going with the MVP. The Prospect is brand new (she killed the last one just before her first fall game and I knew I could get it game-ready in 24-48 hours) so if Santa brings DD a new MVP I should be able to have it ready by spring.
If Santa brings your DD a new MVP, you could have it ready by New Year's Eve, if you really wanted to. Then again, my approach to breaking in gloves tends to be pretty aggressive.