I'm a big fan of the Dynasty with the pitching toe for catchers. You need to be aware that the pitching toe does make the shoe a little clunky for running, which is not an issue for most pitchers but may be for a catcher. Of course, if you're going with a Mid shoe, you're probably not worried about max running speed anyway.
For your pitcher, the Bandit will be lighter and the pitching toe will protect her shoes' longevity perfectly. The Bandit is quite a bit lighter but held up very well for the season my DD used them. We have moved on to Mizunos due to the requirements of our organization, but would happily go back to Ringors if possible.
Thanks Scotty, I was actually hoping to get an opinion from you on this as I know you've used the Ringors before (btw - any suggestions on current discount codes or such?). My Catcher DD is a decent runner but I am concerned about how the Dynasty Mid w/pitching toe will impact that. We might keep a ighter, less protective cleat in her bag for when she's not catching (she also plays 3rd and some outfield).