.............................
Last edited:
Again, that assumes the AD actually cares.
The softball program at my DDs' HS went through a mass exodus of players the coach's second year. Some, like my DD 1 and some of her friends, simply didn't sign up for softball after her freshman year. A large group of girls quit mid-season, including some good players. The number of teams went down from 3 to 2 for several years, and they even had to consolidate teams mid-season. There were no repercussions for the coach. My DD 3 is now a sophomore, and between now and the start of her freshman year, I have seen 4 of the best players leave the program. In 3 of the cases I am 100% sure it was issues with the coaching, esp. the head coach.
What are your thoughts on High school coach talking negatively about one of the players to some third party?
Before the AD at the local HS was AD, he was a math teacher (a very good one, according to my DS) and an asst. basketball coach at a time when the basketball team was a monster program.
This year, no football nor basketball players are signing with D-I schools. Some are signing D-II or D-III. There are athletes in the "lesser" sports, such as swimming and softball, who are signing for D-I. Anyway, the AD decided NOT to have a signing ceremony at the HS, since the IMPORTANT sports are not involved.
One of my cousins was a walk-on in the football program at OU. It was a complete mess then, although their HC did later win a Super Bowl. My cousin turned down a scholarship at Colorado because his father had played at OU, and he had been an OU fan from birth.
I heard the stories from my mother who heard it from my aunt, because my cousin would never bad mouth the program in public, and that included cousins.
My cousin left after his freshman year. The HC never talked to the players, but had a bevy of co-ed groupies who would watch the practice with him. After practice, HC would leave with his groupies. Setting a fine example for the young players. My parents taught at the HC's alma mater, and the HC's son was in one of my mother's classes. My mother felt bad for the kid, knowing that everyone knew the kid's father was regularly cheating on the kid's mother.
One time, some of the players bought guns on a trip to Miami. It used to be an OU football tradition to buy guns in Miami. Don't ask me why, since guns are plentiful in Oklahoma. My cousin took some of these kids out to his parent's place for target practice, to teach them how to shoot a gun properly and safely. One of those players later shot another player.
But, the team kept winning, and that was all that mattered at OU.
Who is the 3rd party? The HC and AC have frank discussions about players. In some situations, the HC, AC, the AD, a HS dean and the HS principal are involved. These discussions are necessary and required.
If you are talking about the third party being someone not affiliated with the school, then you have to look at the context and exactly what was said.
Before I could tell you if I think it's wrong or not, I need to know:The third party was someone not involved with the HS program in any way. The problem I see about a coach bad mouthing a kid is, it takes years to build good reputation and it takes only one bad story to bring it all down. When negative things are said about a kids character by a coach, it holds value even if they are not true. For example, a coach calls a pitch and the pitcher misses her spot, will it be right for the coach to tell someone that the pitcher is pitching her own game and not listening to the coach? Being insubordinate to a coach in a game situation is not what a kid want to be associated with.
The third party was someone not involved with the HS program in any way. The problem I see about a coach bad mouthing a kid is, it takes years to build good reputation and it takes only one bad story to bring it all down. When negative things are said about a kids character by a coach, it holds value even if they are not true. For example, a coach calls a pitch and the pitcher misses her spot, will it be right for the coach to tell someone that the pitcher is pitching her own game and not listening to the coach? Being insubordinate to a coach in a game situation is not what a kid want to be associated with.