Over many years I have worked with quite a few D1 pitchers and have a pretty good idea how it works. In your example I suspect that her new PC found her not to be just illegal, but her mechanics were a mess. No reputable PC would ever try to replicate Barnhills mechanics, and would agree that she is successful despite her mechanics, not because of them. What you describe is a non-typical D1 pitcher who like Barnhill has significant mechanical issues. Because these pitchers are surrounded by enablers who never hold them accountable, they never develop solid pitching mechanics. As you describe they could blow the ball by hitters and as we often hear they "never get call for it in HS/TB."
What I was referring to with pitchers like Nickie Blue and Kaitlin Lee are pitchers who by most standards are mechanically sound, and may have a slight leap. Those pitchers, like the vast majority of others out there are quite capable of complying with the existing pitching rules. If the rules were vigorously enforced they will not need to leave the game and will carry on as effective as before. They do not need to have the rules changed in order for them to continue to compete at the highest level because of poor mechanics. Not enforcing the rules and giving pitchers with poor mechanics a pass does not do them any favors, as they never reach their full potential. As long as they are rewarded with artificial success there is zero incentive to achieve true success.
Last edited:
