Are you looking for a high end option that will last a long time or something more reasonable as she it seems she is new to the position? An MVP Prime is a great option on the cheaper side and the softer leather will be much easier than a higher end model to get into game shape as the season is...
Hi! I didn't play softball (baseball) but loved the Liberty series from back when it was Worth. I always thought they were the most comfortable! I would highly recommend them!
There is not going to be any difference in quality of the black and brown version of the same glove. It is going to be a personal preference. I've always been a fan of brown personally!