Thread: Dilemma

Originally Posted by glf0845

Jenny Finch would not be "Jenny Finch" if she did not commit to softball. There are few athletes who become elite in one sport playing several. I know there are exceptions but not many and exceptions can be made. But, I find it hard to believe that 1/2 the team are gifted athletes.

Sorry, but I just don't agree with that statement. For example, if you go back and look at how many pro athletes were multi sport athletes in high school, it's mind boggling. John Elway, Dan Marino, etc., etc. The list goes on and on and includes most of the NFL and MLB Hall of Famers. Kids specializing in one sport is a fairly recent thing. I realize that it gets frustrating when kids miss softball practice for other sports, but you have to realize that those "other sports" are excellent cross training for a softball player. The results can be quicker reflexes, faster running speed, better hand eye coordination, more explosiveness, etc.
This is why D1 coaches love multi sport athletes.

The results can be quicker reflexes, faster running speed, better hand eye coordination, more explosiveness, etc.

I think it's OK for the outfielders, as long as they have always had a 300 or better avg.

Originally Posted by Perfect Circle

I think it's OK for the outfielders, as long as they have always had a 300 or better avg.

How about a pitcher who hit for over 500 last year? Think she can handle it?

Originally Posted by chinamigarden

the person I replied to said if a girl wants to play other sports she should not commit to a travel softball team. I was just pointing out the silliness of that statement by pointing out that very committed and skilled athletes have played more then one sport.

(I am about to channel my inner Screwball) Why is it that when a boy plays more then one sport its fine, but a girl has to abandon everything else in order to be committed. The school my dd goes to has less then 300 girls, yet our sports teams generally play in the larger divisions of our conference. Our softball team plays in a division where most of the schools have graduating classes larger then our school. Its not because we have a girls who specialize in one sport, its because we have a bunch of 3 sport athletes who play everything.

Edit to ad, I just caught the last point in your post. Are you kidding me? Few elite in one sport played multiple? Professional sports are full of such players. Like I said we are a small school, in the past 5 years our school has produced 4 division 1 athletes and a handful of division 2, and a boatload of division 3 athletes. Every single one of them played 2 or more sports, 3 was the norm and one girl lettered in 4 sports. The other school in our school district is a bit bigger and has had similar to slightly larger numbers of kids moving on to play in college and most of those played 2-3 sports in HS. The one girl was a pitcher on her travel team, on the HS team plus played volleyball, basketball and pole vaulted on the HS team and traveled the country competing in track and field events. She is now at a Big Ten School on a scholarship for Pole Vault. I would venture to guess that she would be considered an elite athlete (her state record in the PV would be evidence of that) and yet she played other sports.

We will have to agree to disagree. Maybe it is done differently in the rest of the country because I don't see it with my DD's softball friends and team mates. In fact, none of her softball friends and team mates play another high school sport. Her TB team is so competitive if you don't make practices or you miss tournaments your play time is severely affected. The only excused absences are college camps, unofficial/official visits or SAT/ACT testing. But we all make our choices.

Originally Posted by SoccerDad

Sorry, but I just don't agree with that statement. For example, if you go back and look at how many pro athletes were multi sport athletes in high school, it's mind boggling. John Elway, Dan Marino, etc., etc. The list goes on and on and includes most of the NFL and MLB Hall of Famers. Kids specializing in one sport is a fairly recent thing. I realize that it gets frustrating when kids miss softball practice for other sports, but you have to realize that those "other sports" are excellent cross training for a softball player. The results can be quicker reflexes, faster running speed, better hand eye coordination, more explosiveness, etc.
This is why D1 coaches love multi sport athletes.

You are right....and these are the exceptions. Pro athletes, whatever sport, are gifted athletes and a minute percentage. But the average athlete, who is not gifted, and wants to be an elite athlete has to put more time and effort into that sport. JMHO

Originally Posted by glf0845

You are right....and these are the exceptions. Pro athletes, whatever sport, are gifted athletes and a minute percentage. But the average athlete, who is not gifted, and wants to be an elite athlete has to put more time and effort into that sport. JMHO

What? Pro athletes were not Pro's in HS, sure seems like a whole bunch of exceptions since there is a whole bunch of Pro athletes, which the majority of them played several sports in HS. Sorry a non-gifted athlete will never be an elite athlete so don't try and use that argument. Like I said I believe it is narrow-minded of a coach to bench a player because of another sport (If softball is out of season)

Originally Posted by CoachKevin

What? Pro athletes were not Pro's in HS, sure seems like a whole bunch of exceptions since there is a whole bunch of Pro athletes, which the majority of them played several sports in HS. Sorry a non-gifted athlete will never be an elite athlete so don't try and use that argument. Like I said I believe it is narrow-minded of a coach to bench a player because of another sport (If softball is out of season)

Coach Kevin,
Just a discussion here. It's OK to have a different opinion. I think our definition of an elite athlete is different. I'm not talking about pro athletes, I am talking about a softball player who can play D1 in college. I am not the coach who expects full on commitment, they just happen to be in the area my DD plays. But where we play the fall season is a season and I agree it might be narrow-minded but such is the case. We are not in a position to switch areas and I happen to like Ca.
The pro athlete is such a small percentage of the whole athletic population and they are pro for a reason; I don't think that's a "whole bunch". Again, JMHO