Should you teach young catchers to throw from the knees?

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

May 15, 2013
1
0
Marc,

To answer your question, I don't think it's something you should spend an entire winter on. I think with that particular skill, a lot of catchers can either do it or not. Some are just that athletic/strong/skilled etc and can do it and do it well and don't need much coaching.

Others may be able to add it to their arsenal for special situations opportunities (not an every time thing) so it's fine to work with them on it a little, just to introduce it, give them the basics. But since they aren't going to be using it even half the time, I don't feel it's wise to spend a huge chunk of time on it.

The rest, even with tons of coaching on it will probably never be able to effectively use it, so why waste the time. Use it to further strengthen their other skills that they WILL be using on a regular basis.


----------

Side note: my 8-year-old is catching this year for the first time every so often. I notice that sometimes when she throws back to the pitcher, rather than stand and throw, she goes to her knees and does it. I don't think anyone "taught" it to her and I'm actually kind of surprised at the quality of her throw and her mechanics when she does it. Her upper body mechanics may be even slightly better throwing from the knees than when she stands and throws. She takes her time since no one is one base and makes a nice throw. I didn't catch much, so I don't now, but does doing this help "save" her legs a little during the game vs standing every time? It seems like it would, but like I said, I haven't been in that situation much and it was years ago, so I don't really know.

I haven't seen a reason to stop her from doing it, so I've just let it go. Is there any way in which this would be a negative thing?

I absolutely agree with an 8 year old practicing the leg work which will be required as she matures even at the instructional league caliber. Also, the only other reason why I would want my catcher to refrain from getting into the habit of dropping to her knees is in the event of a delayed attempt to steal home and a wild throw back from the pitcher that she may not handle from that position. However, I realize at that age you don't have to worry about delayed steals home, but hopefully she doesn't retain that habit as she advances to older play.
 
May 23, 2013
18
0
My daughter is a 10u lefty blessed with a cannon for an arm. Her throw-down to second from pop-pop is 2.2-2.45 seconds. We are currently working on the knee throw. Jen Schro is who we are currently learning this technique from. The one warning she does have is, never let your elbow drop below your shoulder and use your legs. Check out Jen Schro, she has awesome clinics and videos.
 
Last edited:
Jul 10, 2011
151
18
Rockport, MA
Silver,

While your daughter may have a strong arm for her age, if she isn't coming out of her crouch at 55-60MPH in overhand velocity, she is most likely losing time in her throw towards her target and risking far too much by throwing from her knees. Not saying the move doesn't have merit even with the loss of velocity, there's something to be said for deceptiveness of that throw, but at that age, with her body and arm still developing, there is far too much risk of injury to the arm should her mechanics be off for just one of those throws.

The catchers I train know that if they come to me about throwing to the bases from their knees, the next step is me pulling out a radar gun and testing the viability of their individual throw. If you're not at least 50 MPH from your knees, there is literally no point to risking that throw. IMHO, it is far more important to build proper throwing mechanics and footwork by standing up and throwing at that age than trying to pull off a throw that has no actual advantage at her age.

By the way, in 8 popular college showcases around the country last year, a total of 4,771 girls had their overhand velocity tested. The average velocity was 50MPH. There were less than 40 girls to reach 60MPH (Thanks to Austin Wasserman of A.B. Athletics for the info).
 

Forum statistics

Threads
42,856
Messages
680,184
Members
21,504
Latest member
winters3478
Top