Teaching hitting "the right way" : an epiphany

Welcome to Discuss Fastpitch

Your FREE Account is waiting to the Best Softball Community on the Web.

Oct 4, 2011
663
0
Colorado
DH's and my weekends are pretty open right now. DD is out with a back injury and DS is out with a broken collar bone so suddenly DH and I have a lot of time on our hands. DH wanted to work on his own hitting, so he asked me to feed the pitching machine for a few hours. I complied, then, thinking that hitting looked like a lot more fun than feeding the machine, asked for a hitting lesson.

I learned that I can put the bat on the ball while swinging "my way" - which is really really bad - pretty much everything that you coaches can think of that is wrong with a swing - I did that. DH then taught me the "right way" - I won't go into the technicalities which I can't even begin to describe, but I'll just generally say "the right way" - as in, a swing that looks like the GIFs that are posted of actual, real baseball and softball players.

Hitting the ball "the right way" is really hard. I must have swung and missed 50 times. Truly. I wanted to go back to "my way", and said so. DH implored me to keep trying, and at about the 70th swing, I actually made contact. After about 20 more swings, I started to make REALLY GOOD contact - like hitting it to the fence! Woohoo! I can now hit 50 mph pitching like nobody's business. 55 - not so much. After hitting 5 in a row off the hands I cried uncle. We cleaned up the field and called it a day.

Here's the epiphany: it is tempting to let a strong, athletic youth player hit the ball "her way" if she can muscle it past the infield and make it to first base. You may try to teach her proper mechanics, but she'll get frustrated. She won't articulate this to you the way a 40 year old wife will to her husband. She'll just be frustrated and may quietly try to sneak back to doing it her own way. Don't let her - watch her like a hawk. Use tons of positive praise as she swings and misses hundreds of times. Eventually, if you MAKE her stick with it, she'll connect "the right way" - the feeling is wonderful. The first time I really got one on the barrel - it felt like nothing - like I was hitting a ball made out of air. I couldn't believe it as I watched the ball sail to the fence.

So that's my epiphany. I thought I'd post it here because a lot of coaches, who have been swinging "the right way" for 30 years or more, may not remember how hard it is to learn. I think it was a helpful exercise for DH to teach me how to hit. I learned how hard hitting is (parents: don't wonder why your kid struck out - wonder how she hit it at all) and DH learned how it can be really hard to teach hitting at first, but that they WILL get it eventually, if they are MADE to stick with the proper mechanics.
 
Last edited:
Nov 6, 2013
771
16
Baja, AZ
Indiana, I also hope your kids are back in action soon. Congrats on feeling the "right way."

I agree with Indiana and OILF that we need to watch our kids and support good habits. My DD is not as reluctant to listen to me and what I learn here on DFP, but she still prefers her hitting coach over me. At a recent lesson I saw her take her new bat (she named it "The Chosen Juan") and successfully couple the rear load and coil, putting the swing together better than she ever has. She has had a pretty swing for awhile now, has always been a solid hitter, but her hitting coach just sparked her timing to the next level.
 
Last edited:
Oct 4, 2011
663
0
Colorado
I only have one question....how sore were you the next day?!

Ha ha! I was sore in my upper back - in between my shoulder blades and then down to my mid-back. My legs were also a little sore. Hitting off the hands hurts - a lot! I remembered the feeling from my field hockey days. Mis-hitting a field hockey ball gives the same sensation, but not nearly as bad.

DD listens to her dad pretty well now (16 years old), but didn't want anything to do either of us at age 13. That was when the right hitting coach was extremely worthwhile, if only to validate what DH had been saying all along.

I think all parents should have to: 1) catch fly balls -a terrifying prospect if you are not a ball player ; 2) field hard hit, bouncing grounders - but with a mask ; and 3) take a legit hitting lesson. Oh and maybe 4) catch a ball that is absolutely rifled to you from a cannon-like arm - also terrifying. DH used to beg me to play catch with him - I complied but only if I could use my lacrosse stick and only if he would throw ONLY to the stick, which I held as far away from my body as possible. Lacrosse - no problem whatsoever, even back in the days when all we wore on our face was a mouthguard. Catch a baseball? No. Way. In. Heck.
 

Greenmonsters

Wannabe Duck Boat Owner
Feb 21, 2009
6,166
38
New England
Ha ha! I was sore in my upper back - in between my shoulder blades and then down to my mid-back. My legs were also a little sore. Hitting off the hands hurts - a lot! I remembered the feeling from my field hockey days. Mis-hitting a field hockey ball gives the same sensation, but not nearly as bad.

DD listens to her dad pretty well now (16 years old), but didn't want anything to do either of us at age 13. That was when the right hitting coach was extremely worthwhile, if only to validate what DH had been saying all along.

I think all parents should have to: 1) catch fly balls -a terrifying prospect if you are not a ball player ; 2) field hard hit, bouncing grounders - but with a mask ; and 3) take a legit hitting lesson. Oh and maybe 4) catch a ball that is absolutely rifled to you from a cannon-like arm - also terrifying. DH used to beg me to play catch with him - I complied but only if I could use my lacrosse stick and only if he would throw ONLY to the stick, which I held as far away from my body as possible. Lacrosse - no problem whatsoever, even back in the days when all we wore on our face was a mouthguard. Catch a baseball? No. Way. In. Heck.

Good for you Indy! Your next George Plimpton-esqe amateur softball assignment is to catch a live batting practice session. With all the protective gear on it doesn't normally hurt (that much or for that long)! Looking forward to another fine first-person perspective story!

FWIW, when I was 12 I threw hard and was wild so none of my brothers or any of my neighborhood friends would catch me. Brave ol' Mom saved the day so I could practice pitching (smart too, as she wore a mask!) and made possible my best (and only) LL pitching performance - a 1 H, 14 K, 4 HBP, 10 BB 6-inning complete game 8-6 victory!
 

Greenmonsters

Wannabe Duck Boat Owner
Feb 21, 2009
6,166
38
New England
Ha ha! I was sore in my upper back - in between my shoulder blades and then down to my mid-back. My legs were also a little sore. Hitting off the hands hurts - a lot! I remembered the feeling from my field hockey days. Mis-hitting a field hockey ball gives the same sensation, but not nearly as bad.

DD listens to her dad pretty well now (16 years old), but didn't want anything to do either of us at age 13. That was when the right hitting coach was extremely worthwhile, if only to validate what DH had been saying all along.

I think all parents should have to: 1) catch fly balls -a terrifying prospect if you are not a ball player ; 2) field hard hit, bouncing grounders - but with a mask ; and 3) take a legit hitting lesson. Oh and maybe 4) catch a ball that is absolutely rifled to you from a cannon-like arm - also terrifying. DH used to beg me to play catch with him - I complied but only if I could use my lacrosse stick and only if he would throw ONLY to the stick, which I held as far away from my body as possible. Lacrosse - no problem whatsoever, even back in the days when all we wore on our face was a mouthguard. Catch a baseball? No. Way. In. Heck.

Good for you Indy! When you are sufficiently recovered, your next George Plimpton-esqe amateur softball assignment is to catch a live batting practice session. With all the protective gear on it doesn't normally hurt (that much or for that long)! Looking forward to another fine first-person perspective posting!

FWIW, when I was 12 I threw hard and was wild so none of my brothers or any of my neighborhood friends would catch me. Brave ol' Mom saved the day so I could practice pitching (smart too, as she wore a mask!) and made possible my best (and only) LL pitching performance - a 1 H, 14 K, 4 HBP, 10 BB 6-inning complete game 8-6 victory!
 
Oct 4, 2011
663
0
Colorado
Not a bad outing for 12U Little League - put the fear of God into 'em, I say. Good on the kid who stayed in the box for the 1H :) I caught for DD once during an indoor lesson. All geared up I looked the same as any other 14 year old girl, except the coaches watching wondered why on earth DD's catcher was so terrible. When I took the gear off and glanced over I could feel their palpable relief as they realized that I was a mom. Yeah, I would have caught for you, too. Just one of those things we moms do.

My favorite George Plimpton book was the one he wrote about the Bruins (of course!). Live batting practice - no thank you! It was hard enough catching DD when there wasn't a kid standing in my way with a bat that could surely kill me with one errant follow through. I may ask DH to throw live to me, though. Now that I can hit the straight down the middle fastball I'm wondering how I'll do with change-ups and of course with the fear of the ball hitting me!
 
Last edited:

Greenmonsters

Wannabe Duck Boat Owner
Feb 21, 2009
6,166
38
New England
Not a bad outing for 12U Little League - put the fear of God into 'em, I say. Good on the kid who stayed in the box for the 1H :) I caught for DD once during an indoor lesson. All geared up I looked the same as any other 14 year old girl, except the coaches watching wondered why on earth DD's catcher was so terrible. When I took the gear off and glanced over I could feel their palpable relief as they realized that I was a mom. Yeah, I would have caught for you, too. Just one of those things we moms do.

My favorite George Plimpton book was the one he wrote about the Bruins (of course!). Live batting practice - no thank you! It was hard enough catching DD when there wasn't a kid standing in my way with a bat that could surely kill me with one errant follow through. I may ask DH to throw live to me, though. Now that I can hit the straight down the middle fastball I'm wondering how I'll do with change-ups and of course with the fear of the ball hitting me!

You must give DH credit, he's a better man than I - awfully hard to resist throwing one high and tight just to see your reaction!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
42,862
Messages
680,266
Members
21,517
Latest member
coopdog
Top